Coughlin hearing echoes of ‘Goodbye Allie’Posted: December 8, 2015
Way back in the mid-60s, New York Giants fans at Yankee Stadium serenaded coach Allie Sherman with taunts of “Goodbye Allie” as they expressed their displeasure with the team’s performance. Although fans are not nearly as vocal about Tom Coughlin these days, many feel it’s time for the Giants to make a change.
Coughlin will always be revered in New York for winning a pair of Super Bowls, twice beating the Patriots in dramatic fashion. But after yet another fourth quarter meltdown Sunday, this one against the Jets, it’s apparent that Coughlin’s coaching days are numbered.
The Giants have blown fourth-quarter leads in five of their seven losses this year, and some of the blame needs to come down on the coach. Clock mismanagement, bad coaching decisions, questionable play-calling, lack of execution and pure dumb luck have cost the Giants wins against Dallas, Atlanta, New Orleans, New England and the Jets.
The Giants have failed to make the playoffs since winning the Super Bowl in 2012, finishing 9-7, 7-9, 6-10 and currently 5-7. That doesn’t look pretty in a line graph, never mind in the NFL standings. Amazingly, Big Blue could still make the playoffs if the Giants win the woeful NFC East.
Allie Sherman experienced a similar fall-off in the 60s. After taking the Giants to three consecutive NFL Championship games beginning in 1961, all of which they lost, the Giants failed to make the playoffs for 18 straight years. Despite marks of 2-10-2 in 1964 and a club-record worst 1-12-1 in 1966, Sherman clung to his job until 1969, when after a terrible pre-season he was replaced by Alex Webster. Overall, Sherman was 57-51-4 with the Giants.
This is Coughlin’s 12th season with the Giants, and his teams have compiled a 101-87 record. He has coached more games and earned more victories than all but one other Giant – Hall of Famer Steve Owen who finished 151-100-17 between 1931 and 1953 and won a pair of championships.
If the Giants do decide to part ways with Coughlin, they should look outside-house for a replacement. Steve Spagnola’s defense is a mess, one of the worst outfits in the league. And despite some talent, Ben McAdoo’s offense is terribly inconsistent. (Memo to Ben: running back by committee doesn’t work, at least not with this offensive line.)
Is Coughlin a Hall of Fame coach? He did win those two Super Bowls, and his overall playoff record with the Giants is 8-3. He also coached the Jacksonville Jaguars, an expansion team, to a 68-60 mark, and took them to a pair of AFC Championship games. He will certainly receive strong consideration for a bust in Canton.
Only one eligible coach – Tom Flores of the Raiders – has won two Super Bowls and is not a member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame. But even Hall of Fame coaches lose their jobs.